![]() ![]() Photo courtesy of Peter Biles Peter Biles Writer and Editor, Center for Science & Culture Peter Biles graduated from Wheaton College in Illinois and went on to receive a Master of Fine Arts in Creative Writing from Seattle Pacific University. What are we giving up, though, when we forego the struggle? We might miss out on actual meaning-making, as well as the ability to do the hard work of thinking, synthesizing, and coming to our own conclusions.ĬhatGPT’s conversational model gives it the illusion of conversationality, but it’s still an algorithm. Jeffrey Bilbro, What Problem Does ChatGPT Solve? by Jeffrey Bilbro ()īilbro notes that ChatGPT takes the struggle out of a process that formerly demanded mental effort and frustration. No technological shortcut, no forbidden fruit, will alter this creatural reality. But we gain the competence to meet these challenges responsibly only by careful, effortful practice. If your life on Earth is going to be a hardscrabble in dying soil, or a struggle to survive in a lawless megacity slum, why continue it any longer than necessary?” Tasks such as writing well, thinking well, and living well are hard, particularly for fallen and fallible creatures. One of the agents for this AI entices these remaining persons to upload their consciousness onto the AI and escape the difficulties of existence: “As Alexandria became more accessible, everyone wanted in. Paul Kingsnorth dramatizes this lure in his dystopian novel Alexandria, about a remnant community of humans holding out against a massive AI. This thing can do whatever I ask it to do! What is less apparent is the seductive power such tools exercise over us. When we sit in front of a computer typing prompts into ChatGPT and watching it effortlessly spit out sentence after sentence, we may experience the rush of power. It’s easier to make money rearranging words according to various probabilities than it is to make a living improving the health of our topsoil, communities, and souls. LLMs are a technology suited to a decadent culture, one that chases easy profits rather than tackles the real challenges we face. ![]() He sees ChatGPT as a soulless mechanism that will atrophy our ability to write and diminish our appreciation for good writing. Literature is a “conversation,” requiring sentient minds. Bilbro comes to the issue from a literary background, which means he values the human element in language as a mode of communication. Jeffrey Bilbro, professor of English at Grove City College and an editor at The Front Porch Republic, wrote an article for Plough on what he regards as the primary weakness of Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT. Share Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Flipboard Print arroba Emailĭr.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |